I have noted an editorial in Bowls Plus Magazine
positing that some special regulation should be applied to bowlers who use bowling arms because they create an unfair advantage. It is claimed that these 'armed' bowlers make errors of line only about 2% of the time while regular 'hand' bowlers make errors around 30-35% of the time. These numbers come from the letter’s author, Geoff Mathers of MCC-Kew Sports Club Inc., Victoria in Australia, who claims to have watched both types of bowlers extensively.
Two points arise in my mind that follow from this. First of all, this data must pertain to run-of-the-mill, club bowlers like so many of us! Good match-play bowlers do not miss their line so often. You can gather your own statistics watching on Youtube. Second, I think if this is correct it should be teaching us regular ‘hand’ bowlers something about how to improve ourselves.
What would give ‘arm’ bowlers such a big advantage? Think about it. I can think of two possibilities.
First, the ‘arm’ bowler does not need to lower his/her body to release the bowl onto the green. Lowering your body by bending your knees while simultaneously swinging your arm can disturb your balance more than just swinging your arm the way the ‘arm’ bowler is required to do. This points to the importance for us unassisted bowlers of starting with our advancing foot somewhat forward so that our body lowering can be minimized by being already closer to the ground. Also, the ‘hand’ bowler can stabilize his/her body during the stepping forward by resting one hand on the forward stepping knee. This extra stabilization is not available to the ‘arm’ bowler. But many ‘hand’ bowlers do not use these elements in their deliveries. Having given up two advantages that would strengthen their balance, perhaps, it is these less-experienced bowlers who are complain the most about the supposed unfairness.
Another possibility is that the ‘arm’ bowlers get a clearer, more consistent view of the correct line because their bowl is released from a more upright position so that the ‘armed’ bowler can easily keep his/her eyes fixed on an aim point on the forward ditch. The ‘hand’ bowler often finds it a great strain on the neck to stare at a point on the forward ditch while simultaneously bending down to grass his/her bowl. If this is the cause of the large discrepancy in holding the correct line, it may just need to be reemphasized that ‘hand’ bowlers should pick out their line while standing upright (like the ‘arm’ bowler) behind the mat, then select the appropriate stare point on that line, position themselves correctly on the mat, and deliver their bowl over that stare point.
I do not think even we club bowlers will miss our line 30-35% of the time so long as we maintain the proper pre-shot routine. Perhaps the posited success of bowlers using a bowling arm can assist us all to be better.
One player is using a mechanical device to deliver the bowl while the player is not, so it comes down to this. You have 2 players one playing free hand the other with an artificial device in the same game this is a joke. Could someone let me know what other sport allows type of arrangement?
ReplyDeleteYour comment implies that you think that using an arm is an advantage. Why then are there no arm bowlers in Aust team, state teams or higher levels of pennants. If it was an advantage wouldn't bowlers who play at higher levels be using them too?
ReplyDeleteReply from the Greenbowler: The upper limit for bowling performance is higher for players not using a bowling arm; however, the median performance among all regular quality bowlers can still be higher for people using bowling arms. The arm reduces the demands on the average bowler but also reduces the maximum obtainable performance.
ReplyDeleteI bowl with a mechanical bowling arm and I am over 80 and I am bowling as well (good) as when I was 50 but not better. Of course we bowl better with an arm why would we change to an arm to play worse, I was dropping my bowls, and now I mostly get them away well. But that said we all have limits to our abilities.
ReplyDeleteWith my delivery with the bowling arm I’m hanging on to long which gives a terrible delivery very upsetting
ReplyDeleteAs a competitive bowler who has gone from not using an arm to an arm. Both have their individual strengths and weaknesses. Hardest issue is weight control for an arm bowler. It’s extremely hard to take a metre of weight off and have the same accuracy as a non arm bowler. I find it hard to source coaching tools to develop my game as an arm bowler. It is easy to hit the ground with a bowling arm and it may occasionally drop out. Bowlers need to understand that every ones biomechanics are different and we all adapt differently. Just because I am playing well doesn’t mean it’s all because of the arm, It’s years of practice, training and studying the conditions like wind and grass speed that has done that. If you can’t find your line as a normal player and arm isn’t suddenly going to fix that. I think it’s about time players understand the skill that goes into mastering the bowling arm.
ReplyDelete